GW Law Faculty Publications & Other Works
Document Type
Book Part
Publication Date
2011
Status
Accepted
Abstract
Theory can have profound effects on practice, some intended and desirable, others unintended and undesirable. That's the story of the influence the field of law and economics has had on the domain of law and accounting. That influence comes primarily from agency theory and modern finance theory, specifically through the efficient capital market hypothesis and capital asset pricing model. Those theories have forged considerable change in federal securities regulation, accounting standard setting, state corporation law, and financial auditing. Affected areas include the nature of disclosure, the measure of financial concepts, the limits of shareholder protection, and the scope of auditor duty.
Analysis reveals how agency theory and finance theory often but not always point to the same policy implications; it reveals how finance theory’s assumptions and limitations are often but not always respected in policy development. As a result, while these theories sometimes produced policy changes that were both intended and desirable, some policy changes were both unintended and undesirable while others were intended but undesirable. Examination stresses the power of ideas and how they are used and cautions creators and users of ideas to take care to appreciate the limits of theory when shaping practice. That's vital since the effects of law and economics on law and accounting remain debated in many contexts.
GW Paper Series
GWU Law School Public Law Research Paper No. 531; GWU Legal Studies Research Paper No. 531
SSRN Link
http://ssrn.com/abstract=1776106
Recommended Citation
Lawrence A. Cunningham, The Influence of Law and Economics on Law and Accounting: Two Steps Forward, One Step Back in RESEARCH HANDBOOK ON THE ECONOMICS OF CORPORATE LAW (Claire Hill & Brett McDonnell, eds., Edward Elgar, 2011-2012)